NFL 2023 Week 17: Biggest questions, risers and takeaways

Week 17 of the NFL season started Thursday night with Cleveland Browns quarterback Joe Flacco continuing his hot streak in another Browns win. The Dallas Cowboys held on after some controversy for a key win over the Detroit Lions in a battle of two of the NFC’s best Saturday night.

On Sunday, the San Francisco 49ers clinched the NFC’s No. 1 seed, the Baltimore Ravens clinched the AFC’s No. 1 seed and the Chicago Bears clinched the No. 1 overall pick (from Carolina) in the 2024 NFL draft.

Our NFL Nation reporters reacted to all the action, answering lingering questions coming out of each game and picking out who — or what — is rising and falling for every team. Let’s get to it.

Jump to a matchup:
NYJ-CLE | DET-DAL | SF-WSH | CAR-JAX
BUF-NE | ARI-PHI | TEN-HOU | LAR-NYG
LV-IND | MIA-BAL | NO-TB | ATL-CHI

Bears

Why can’t the Bears put teams away? Chicago carried a 21-7 lead into halftime, then thundered out of the gate in the third quarter when Justin Fields hit DJ Moore for a 28-yard gain (one of five catches he made over 20 yards) and Khalil Herbert ripped off a big run, only for Chicago to end the drive with a field goal. The offense struggled to get in a rhythm and the Bears let a listless Falcons team hang around until late in the game. Fields said the issues with the offense starting fast and stalling stem from a lack of execution and “a little bit of complacency.” That’s been a theme, even in wins, for Chicago, which found out late in the fourth quarter that it had clinched the No. 1 overall pick in the 2024 NFL draft.

Stock up after the win: WR DJ Moore. Every catch the Bears’ No. 1 wide receiver made against Atlanta was more impressive than his last. Moore recorded his fifth 100-yard receiving game of the season and reached a new single-season career high in receiving yards (1,300) and receiving yards per game (81.3).

Stock down after the win: WR Tyler Scott. The rookie wide receiver had plenty of opportunities to capitalize on an expanded role with Darnell Mooney (concussion) sidelined. Scott received two of his five targets in the end zone. On his first, he couldn’t come down with two feet in bounds in the back of the end zone, which led the Bears to kick a field goal. On his second, Scott couldn’t haul in a 33-yard pass that would’ve been a touchdown. — Courtney Cronin

Next game: at Packers

---

Falcons

Did the Falcons (still in the NFC South race) show anything that suggests they can win next week? In a year in which inconsistency has been the theme, it’s nearly impossible to predict whether we’ll see the Atlanta team that dominated the Colts or the one that no-showed against the Bears and Panthers. On a promising note, the Falcons played well against the Saints, their Week 18 opponent, earlier this season, holding New Orleans without a touchdown and gaining 396 yards of offense. Can they do that again? The Falcons have a chance, especially since they’ve typically played well when there has been intense outside criticism. It’s reasonable to think there’s more coming this week.

Stock up after the loss: LB Kaden Elliss. Elliss was a rare bright spot on a defense that struggled against Chicago quarterback Justin Fields all day — notching nine tackles, a sack and a tackle for loss.

Stock down after the loss: Coach Arthur Smith. Smith’s playcalling felt off from the game’s first series, when a direct snap to Bijan Robinson failed miserably and thwarted a drive — portending a day in which four of five possessions in the second and third quarters went for three plays or fewer. Those drives resulted in punts or turnovers, and Atlanta never seemed fully in it once it faced a double-digit deficit. — Michael Rothstein

Next game: at Saints

Saints

Will the Saints make the playoffs? The Saints played their best football of the season when they needed to stay alive in the playoff hunt. Now they’ll have to do it one more time with a win against the Falcons, with some help needed from other teams, as well. New Orleans doesn’t control its own destiny, but the Saints said before the game that they’re already in a playoff mindset because a loss will eliminate them from playoff contention.

Stock up after the win: TE Juwan Johnson. Johnson had a career-best eight catches for 90 yards and scored a touchdown, reinstating the connection he and quarterback Derek Carr showed in training camp.

Stock down after the win: CB Paulson Adebo. It wasn’t easy to find any “stock down” candidates after a big win, but Adebo allowed a few big catches by Bucs wideout Mike Evans and had an illegal contact penalty called against him on third down. — Katherine Terrell

Next game: vs. Falcons

---

Buccaneers

How does this loss impact the Bucs’ playoff chances? Tampa Bay squandered a chance at locking up the division title at home, coming out flat on both sides of the ball, with quarterback Baker Mayfield missing the mark through the air with two interceptions, bobbled passes by the receivers, no pressure on opposing quarterback Derek Carr and zero takeaways on defense. The Bucs still have a 73% chance to win their division if they win next week’s game at the Carolina Panthers, according to ESPN Analytics. If they lose, however, they have just a 0.1% chance to make the playoffs.

Stock up after the loss: CB Zyon McCollum. McCollum was in for a concussed Carlton Davis III and spent the majority of the game lined up against WR Chris Olave, while CB Jamel Dean lined up against WR Rashid Shaheed. Olave caught 3-of-6 targets for 26 yards while Shaheed had just two catches on three targets for 14 yards.

Stock down after the loss: Preparation. Mayfield’s inaccuracy led to two picks; RB Rachaad White lost a fumble; WR Mike Evans was targeted four times despite Marshon Lattimore’s absence; safety Dee Delaney struggled against Juwan Johnson; and several costly penalties cost the Bucs a chance to lock up a division title. Even punter Jake Camarda had a bad game, averaging 41.4 yards per punt. — Jenna Laine

Next game: at Panthers

Ravens

Did Lamar Jackson wrap up the NFL MVP award? It sure looks that way. Jackson, the betting favorite for NFL MVP entering this game, threw five touchdown passes and recorded a perfect passer rating (158.3) to lead the Ravens to the No. 1 seed in the AFC and the AFC North title. Jackson is the best player on the NFL’s best team, and he carried a banged-up Baltimore team on Sunday with 321 yards passing and his first five-TD game since his 2019 MVP season.

Stock up after the win: RB Justice Hill. He caught Jackson’s first touchdown pass to a running back since Week 8 of last season, scoring on a 20-yard wheel route. He also set up a second touchdown with a 78-yard kickoff return to open the second half.

Stock down after the win: Injuries to the secondary. The Ravens were playing all five of their healthy defensive backs for most of the second half. Baltimore entered the game without two starters — safety Kyle Hamilton (knee) and cornerback Brandon Stephens (ankle) — and then watched cornerback Marlon Humphrey (calf) and defensive back Daryl Worley (head) leave the game. — Jamison Hensley

Next game: vs. Steelers

---

Dolphins

How big of a concern is a lopsided loss ahead of the playoffs? You never want to get blown out, but the Dolphins lost in every facet of the game Sunday to a Ravens team that clearly looks like the best in the NFL. The concern is not the fact that Miami lost another road game to a good team — it’s that Miami will likely have to go through this Ravens team if it wants to reach the Super Bowl. This loss doesn’t make the Dolphins a bad team; it does, however, establish a clear hierarchy in the AFC.

Stock up after the loss: RB De’Von Achane. Starting in place of Raheem Mostert, the rookie recorded 137 total yards and a touchdown in what should be a preview of his role in the 2024 season — when he’s the Dolphins’ starting running back.

Stock down after the loss: The secondary. Lamar Jackson hit wide-open receivers throughout the day as the Dolphins blew coverage after coverage and Jackson made them pay. — Marcel Louis-Jacques

Next game: vs. Bills

Colts

Do the Colts have enough offensive firepower to compete in the playoffs? The Colts have been consistently inconsistent on offense, but they show just enough flashes to convince one that they can make a play when needed. On Sunday, we saw it several times. There was Alec Pierce’s 58-yard touchdown on a savvy playcall from coach Shane Steichen, with the Colts dialing up a shot play in a third-and-1 situation. Later, the running game came through with some tough, game-sealing yards. The Colts don’t exactly have a lethal offense, but the combination of strong playcalling and timely playmaking could be enough to make them a threat if they advance to the postseason. This win over the Raiders boosted Indy’s playoff odds to 63%.

Stock up after the win: Running backs. They had a strong day, despite Jonathan Taylor being in and out of the lineup with an apparent injury. Taylor played sparingly in the second half, but when he did, he was particularly efficient. His 96 yards on 21 carries were a season high.

Stock down after the win: The secondary. It was an up-and-down day for the secondary, which played without its top two members (CB Kenny Moore II had a back injury, and S Julian Blackmon was placed on injured reserve last week for a shoulder injury). The Colts yielded a season high in passing yards for Raiders QB Aidan O’Connell (299 yards). — Stephen Holder

Next game: vs. Texans

---

Raiders

Did Antonio Pierce lose his grip on claiming the permanent gig? True, the Raiders officially were eliminated from the playoff race with the flat 23-20 loss at the Colts that dropped Las Vegas’ record to 7-9. And yes, Pierce has changed the culture going 4-4 as the interim coach. But this loss, as well as the 3-0 defeat to the Vikings in Week 14, hurt his case as much as the wins over the Chargers and Chiefs helped him. In short, it’s a wash for now. Up next, another division rival in the Broncos and rampant Jim Harbaugh coaching rumors.

Stock up after the loss: RB Zamir White. The second-year back, making his third straight start in place of injured All-Pro Josh Jacobs (quad), made the most of his touches. He rushed for 71 yards on 20 carries and caught a career-best five passes for a career-high 35 yards.

Stock down after the loss: CB Jack Jones. After pick-sixes in consecutive weeks, Jones committed two penalties on the Colts’ game-sealing drive — a pass interference for pushing the receiver on a ball thrown out of bounds and being offsides on a 50-yard field goal that missed (the Colts then made the ensuing 45-yarder). — Paul Gutierrez

Next game: vs. Broncos

Rams

Will kicker woes doom the Rams? The Rams have an 86% chance to make the playoffs with one game to go, but whether they can make a run during the postseason might depend on what they do at kicker. Lucas Havrisik missed two extra points Sunday, and the Rams barely escaped with a one-point win. Coach Sean McVay has said they like Havrisik, but his missed kicks Sunday may lead to a change. Los Angeles has missed 15 combined field goals and extra points, the most of any team this season, according to ESPN Stats & Information.

Stock up after the win: The tandem of RB Kyren Williams and WR Puka Nacua. Williams had a career-high three rushing touchdowns and Nacua added five catches for 118 yards to lead the offense. Nacua had his seventh game this season with at least 100 receiving yards, tied for the second most by a rookie in NFL history.

Stock down after the win: The secondary. Allowing explosive plays has been an issue for the Rams this season, and it was again when Giants wide receiver Darius Slayton caught an 80-yard pass for a touchdown in the third quarter. — Sarah Barshop

Next game: at 49ers

---

Giants

What are the Giants looking at in terms of draft position? This was a disappointing game for the Giants, unless you’re a fan who mainly cares about how this impacts the draft. Sunday’s result nearly assures the Giants will now select in the top five. New York came into the game in the fifth spot, and ESPN Analytics had it at 72.8% to finishing in the top five. That will only rise after Sunday’s loss. There is a chance the Giants can catch the Commanders or Patriots to move up even higher, depending on next week’s results.

Stock up after the loss: WR Wan’Dale Robinson. This is the second time in the past four games that the Giants have found ways to get the ball into his hands, aside from as a pass-catcher. Robinson rushed for a 24-yard touchdown on an end-around in the second quarter and finished with six catches for 55 yards.

Stock down after the loss: CB Adoree’ Jackson. It was a struggle for the veteran corner once again vs. the Rams. His missed tackle led to Puka Nacua’s 80-yard catch and run in the third quarter, and he allowed five catches for 118 yards on 10 targets in the game. — Jordan Raanan

Next game: vs. Eagles

Bills

Are offensive inconsistencies a concern heading into next week’s showdown for the AFC East title? There’s good reason for concern as this was a sloppy performance. Quarterback Josh Allen had one of his worst passing games of the season (15-of-30, 169 yards, one interception) and was frequently just off on his connection with receivers. The offense was unable to sustain a drive of more than nine plays and only once had a drive longer than 50 yards. With a big challenge to come, Buffalo has to put together a more complete offensive performance against the Miami Dolphins.

Stock up after the win: CB Rasul Douglas. Acquiring him at the trade deadline has turned into quite a move for the Bills. The cornerback recorded two interceptions versus the Patriots and defended a pass that led to a pick by defensive tackle Ed Oliver. In eight games with Buffalo, he now has four interceptions — the most by a Bills defender this season.

Stock down after the win: The red zone offense. This game should not have been as close as it was, considering the Patriots committed four turnovers in the first half. The Bills settled for two field goals inside the 20-yard line in the first quarter, allowing New England to stay in the game. Their 2-for-5 performance in the red zone epitomized the Bills’ offensive inconsistencies. — Alaina Getzenberg

Next game: at Dolphins

---

Patriots

How significant have turnovers been in a disappointing season? The loss to the Bills was a microcosm of the entire season, as the Patriots (four first-half turnovers, one of which was a pick-six) are primed to finish with a negative turnover differential for the first time since the 2005 season. Their 17 straight seasons with a positive turnover differential was the longest streak since the 1970 AFL-NFL merger. The Patriots are minus-10 on the season, with 17 takeaways and 27 giveaways.

Stock up after the loss: KR Jalen Reagor. A 98-yard return to open the game — the first for the Patriots since the 2018 season (Cordarelle Patterson) — got the game off to a strong start. But Reagor also could have been in the stock down category as a WR for a miscommunication when QB Bailey Zappe expected him to run a slant route that led to a 40-yard INT return.

Stock down after the loss: Zappe’s ball security. After playing turnover-free in a Week 15 win, Zappe was shaky early in the game and seemed to be forcing the ball on the first two of his three INTs before he settled into more of a rhythm. — Mike Reiss

Next game: vs. Jets

Cardinals

Have the Cardinals found their offensive rhythm? It sure seems that way. Although they didn’t find the end zone in the first half, they scored touchdowns on their first four drives of the second half and outscored the Eagles 29-10 in the final two quarters — including the game-winning touchdown by running back James Conner with 32 seconds left. Arizona’s offense clicked on all cylinders in the second half and gained 449 yards over the entire game, but the question remains: Can it continue next week?

Stock up after the win: QB Kyler Murray. He played perhaps his best game of his season, which has consisted of just seven games after he returned from an ACL tear he suffered last season. Murray was 25-of-31 passing (80.7%) for 232 yards and three touchdowns passes to lead Arizona to the upset victory, playing near-perfect football over the last two quarters with just one incomplete pass.

Stock down after the win: The Cardinals’ cornerbacks. They struggled all game to keep the Eagles’ receivers at bay, failing to turn their heads at critical moments while Arizona’s defense gave up 184 passing yards. — Josh Weinfuss

Next game: at Cardinals

---

Eagles

Is this Eagles team capable of another Super Bowl run? That feels like a stretch at the moment. The Eagles could have used a blowout win over the Cardinals to give them the sense they were clicking into gear ahead of the postseason. Instead, the defense faltered in the second half, the offense got conservative in the wrong moment during a key fourth-quarter drive, and Philadelphia was handed a serious setback to its chances of securing a top seed in the NFC playoffs. If the Cowboys win in Week 18, the Eagles will likely be on the road for the duration of the playoffs — a bad development for a group that feels like it’s on shaky ground.

Stock up after the loss: WR Julio Jones. He caught a pair of touchdown passes — his first two-TD performance since Week 6 of the 2020 season, when he was a member of the Falcons. At age 34, Jones is the oldest Eagles player with two receiving touchdowns in a game since Irving Fryar in 1997.

Stock down after the loss: The run defense. Long considered a strength of the team, the rush defense had yielded 115 yards on average in its previous three games. It got worse against the Cardinals, who gained 221. Conner’s 128-yard total is the most the Eagles have surrendered to an individual rusher all season. — Tim McManus

Next game: at Giants

Texans

Can C.J. Stroud lead the Texans back to the playoffs? The Texans’ offense, which was averaging 23 points with Stroud under center, looked similar to how it looked before Stroud missed two games. In Stroud’s first game back (concussion), he threw for 213 yards and a touchdown with a passer rating of 102.7. It can be simple for the Texans: If they win in Indianapolis next week, they are in. Stroud threw for 384 yards the last time he played the Colts, but they still came up short.

Stock up after the win: WR Nico Collins. He led Houston with seven catches for 80 yards and continues to show why he’s the team’s No. 1 option.

Stock down after the win: Red zone offense. The Texans went 1-for-3 and had to settle for field goals. — DJ Bien-Aime

Next game: at Colts

---

Titans

Will the Titans show up in the finale? They certainly didn’t show up Sunday, having already been eliminated from the playoff picture. Starting quarterback Will Levis left with an injury in the second quarter after being sacked on a play – a strip sack that was returned for a touchdown. The play was a microcosm of the protection issues for the Titans. Ryan Tannehill replaced Levis, but he was sacked five times — giving the Texans six on the day.

Stock up after the loss: Tannehill. He didn’t put up points, but he came in and showed he can still play at 35. The opening-day starter completed his first 10 passes and went 16-of-20 for 168 yards.

Stock down after the loss: Running game. The Titans averaged 2.5 yards per carry as the offense failed to get going in all phases. — ESPN staff

Next game: vs. Jaguars

49ers

How significant is it that the 49ers clinched the NFC’s No. 1 seed? Very significant. Sunday’s win, paired with the Eagles’ loss to the Cardinals, wrapped up the top seed and a first-round playoff bye. That’s no small thing given that the Niners’ gas tank seems to be running low — especially on defense. And although they still managed to beat Washington, the juggernaut of a few weeks ago has disappeared. A chance to rest banged-up players such as running back Christian McCaffrey and defensive tackle Arik Armstead the next two weeks is critical to their chances to make a deep postseason run.

Stock up after the win: RB Elijah Mitchell. Injuries have plagued Mitchell his whole career and limited him to 10 games this season. But with McCaffrey battling a calf injury, Mitchell got into a rhythm Sunday and finished with 81 yards on 16 carries with a touchdown.

Stock down after the win: Red zone offense. The Niners entered Sunday second in the league in red zone efficiency, scoring a touchdown on 65.6% of those trips, but they struggled against the Commanders, finishing three-of-six for the day. — Nick Wagoner

Next game: vs. Rams

---

Commanders

How did Sam Howell respond to an odd week? Howell was benched Wednesday but then started when Jacoby Brissett (hamstring) couldn’t. For the first half, Howell responded well, completing 9 of 13 passes for 100 yards and a touchdown. He looked confident. However, in the second half a major issue resurfaced: turnovers. He was intercepted at the 49ers’ 2-yard line making a throw under duress. On the next drive he was intercepted again, failing to see a defender. It’s been his downfall.

Stock up after the loss: RB Brian Robinson Jr. He was underused this season and, in flashes, showed Sunday why he can be a help in the future, with 44 yards rushing on 4.8 per carry, plus 32 yards receiving.

Stock down after the loss: Run defense. The linebackers did not help, but neither did the front as San Francisco gashed the Commanders, finishing with 184 yards and averaging 4.7 per carry. — John Keim

Next game: vs. Cowboys

Jaguars

Did the Jaguars get right by ending their four-game losing streak? The Jaguars kept stressing they were hurting themselves during their four-game skid, and the numbers somewhat bear that out: a league-high 10 turnovers, minus-five in turnover differential and 24 penalties. They didn’t turn the ball over and they were penalized once for 15 yards against the Panthers. Even though it came against the worst team in the league, it’s an encouraging sign for a team that seemed to be in a free-fall after an 8-3 start.

Stock up after the win: LB Josh Allen. He needed one sack to tie Calais Campbell’s single-season franchise record of 14.5. He got three and now has 16.5. Allen’s performance was part of a season-high six sacks by the Jaguars.

Stock down after the win: The red zone offense: The Jaguars scored a touchdown on one of five red zone trips. Coach Doug Pederson likely would have been more aggressive on some of those fourth downs had Trevor Lawrence been on the field, but 1-for-5 won’t cut it when they’re playing for the AFC South title in Tennessee next week. — Mike DiRocco

Next game: at Titans

---

Panthers

Should quarterback Bryce Young’s wish list for 2024 start with the offensive line? No doubt. Young was sacked six times Sunday by a defense ranked 27th entering the game, giving him 59 for the season. He has seen pressure from everywhere. Outside of right tackle Taylor Moton and right guard Austin Corbett (on season-ending IR with a knee injury for the second straight year) everyone else’s job is in jeopardy. No quarterback could be effective behind this group.

Stock up after the loss: LB Brian Burns. The edge rusher had his first sack after going four straight games without one and continued to show that second effort, chasing down players for tackles (eight overall) on a day when he left in the first half with a knee injury.

Stock down after the loss: LT Ikem Ekwonu. He was beaten for two sacks on Young in the first half to give him 18 on the season, which is the most by any player regardless of position in the NFL, per ESPN Analytics/NFL Next Gen Stats. — David Newton

Next game: vs. Buccaneers

Saturday

Cowboys

Does this win mean anything for the Cowboys? It’s certainly better than losing a third straight game. The Cowboys have never made a Super Bowl in a season with a three-game losing streak. This was the definition of what Mike McCarthy calls complementary football. The defense came up with key stops in the fourth quarter after Dallas took a second-half lead. The offense — mainly CeeDee Lamb — was able to do just enough, especially in the critical moments. The Cowboys close the regular season next week at Washington. Winning on the road is a must.

Stock up after the win: WR Brandin Cooks. In a game in which Lamb set the Cowboys’ single-season records for catches and receiving yards, breaking marks held by Michael Irvin since 1995, it was Cooks who came up big for Dallas in the clutch. On the go-ahead drive in the fourth quarter, Cooks had a 21-yard grab on third-and-4 against the blitz and scored the touchdown five plays later. It was his seventh score of the season and second straight go-ahead score in the fourth quarter.

Stock down after the win: RB Tony Pollard. There wasn’t a lot of room for Pollard to run for a good portion of the game, and he was able to pick up some tough yards in the second half. But he also had a key drop on the opening possession of the third quarter that could have broken the game open for Dallas. Instead, it was forced to punt and had to slog through a difficult evening. — Todd Archer

Next game: at Washington Commanders

---

Lions

How much will this loss hurt their playoff seeding? Detroit came into this game having already clinched a playoff spot and the NFC North with a shot at reaching the No. 1 seed in the NFC. The Lions are guaranteed at least the No. 3 seed, but with a win, they would have been in the No. 1 spot heading into Sunday with a half-game lead. Now, it’ll be tough to get the top spot, home-field advantage and a first-round bye, but wilder things have happened.

Stock up after the loss: CB Ifeatu Melifonwu. The reigning NFC Defensive Player of the Week snagged another interception in the first quarter and has continued to find a groove after being inserted into the starting lineup in Week 14.

Stock down after the loss: Third-down efficiency. Although the Lions were aggressive on fourth down, they went just 4-for-13 on third downs. — Eric Woodyard

Next game: vs. Minnesota Vikings

Thursday

Browns

Can anyone slow down Joe Flacco? Evidently not. Coming into Thursday, Flacco was already leading the NFL in passing (1,307 yards) dating back to Week 13, when he took over at quarterback. And that was before he threw for 296 yards in the first half, the most in any half of his career, against one of the NFL’s top pass defenses. The way Flacco is slinging it, to go along with their dominant defense, the Browns could be a difficult out for anyone in the playoffs.

Stock up after the win: TE David Njoku. He had 113 receiving yards in the first quarter and is proving he is one of the top receiving threats at his position.

Stock down after the win: Browns WR corps. The Browns were already without wideout Amari Cooper (heel), and then they lost their other key receiver, Elijah Moore, to a head injury during the game. — Jake Trotter

Next game: at Cincinnati Bengals

---

Jets

Do the Jets need to tweak their defense in the offseason? This is supposed to be the strength of the team — a “championship-caliber defense,” coach Robert Saleh likes to say — but it got embarrassed by Joe Flacco & Co. Does this mean it needs to be overhauled? No, this was an outlier — it’s still a solid defense — but the Jets were exposed in the middle of the field. Their linebackers and safeties were torched in pass coverage. They need a playmaking safety.

Stock up after the loss: RB Breece Hall. He went over 100 yards from scrimmage for the second week in a row, finishing with 126 and a touchdown. The Jets need more players like Hall.

Stock down after the loss: LB C.J. Mosley. He’s not at his best when playing in space, and he got lit up by tight end David Njoku. Mosley allowed three receptions for 75 yards as the nearest defender, per Next Gen Stats. — Rich Cimini

Next game: at New England Patriots